Posts Tagged ‘VALUE CREATION’

The Hidden Value of an IP Portfolio – Just ask Dell

Monday, April 8th, 2013

Value creation is the performance of actions that increase the worth of goods, services and businesses. It benefits customers, who receive improved products and services, as well as shareholders of the company who wish to see their stake appreciate over time.

 

How does a company create and maintain value?

Through innovation processes that build a portfolio of patented intellectual property.

 

A company’s value is not only measured by its annual revenue, but also by the worth of its IP portfolio. Intellectual property includes inventions, designs, brands or any other nonphysical assets that add value to a company. Innovation leads to business success, and it is imperative that it is managed and protected. As Attorney Gary Winer has said, “intellectual property law puts a fence around your innovation to keep competitors at bay, so they can’t copy, use, import, or sell it, either accidentally or through reverse engineering.”

In the past few years, Dell has acquired an extensive IP portfolio as it shifted focus from hardware to the tech market. According to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Dell owns 3,449 patents and another 1,660 patent applications pending as of last year. Virginia-based firm M*CAM, which specializes in valuing corporate intellectual property, states that careful analysis of Dell’s IP portfolio has revealed hidden value in the company. Dell’s US patent portfolio includes fixtures for desktop, notebook and mobile devices, battery and power management technology-related patents, hard drives, storage systems, server technologies and wireless patents. Dell certainly understands the value of intellectual property.

While Dell may not be perceived as one of the top innovators in the tech world, it is apparent the business has created value through its substantial IP portfolio. Some of the biggest banks in the world are vying to buyout Dell as negotiations continue this week. Private equity firms Blackstone Group, Silver Lake Partners and billionaire investor Carl Icahn have submitted preliminary offers. If completed, the Dell deal could lead to a $24 billion dollar takeover, the largest leveraged buyout since 2007!

These investors realize that intellectual property can generate real money for a company, and that there is indeed intrinsic value in a company’s intellectual property. If the Dell buyout isn’t proof enough, a year ago Microsoft paid AOL $1 billion for some of its patents.

When thinking about your own approach to IP protection, remember that the wolves are always at the door. Marketing, prudent business measures, and IP (properly cared for and fed) will help your business grow and succeed.

Here are some questions to ask yourself to stay on track:

  • Who handles your organizations patent applications and the “care and feeding” of your IP portfolio?
  • When was your last patent, and what was it for?
  • Have you experienced any recent product counterfeiting or copycat issues and what was the outcome?
  • Does the leadership or Board have Innovation Governance to maximize IP portfolio ROI

 

Look for creative new way to buy and sell patents through IPXI, a new initiative that offers an IP exchange.

 

You can learn more about the above points, including how to protect your ideas, by reading  Robert’s Rules of Innovation. Robert Brands is the founder of InnovationCoach.com and the author of “Robert’s Rules of Innovation”: A 10-Step Program for Corporate Survival, with Martin Kleinman, published by Wiley.

Innovation Balancing Act

Monday, November 12th, 2012

 

On June 15th of this year, Nik Wallenda became the first person ever to walk across the roaring Niagra Falls on a 2-inch wire.

After battling wind swells, and thick mist, Wallenda completed his walk crossing from the United States into Canada.

 

 

He was greeted by a Canadian customs agent who asked, “What is the purpose of your trip sir?”  Wallenda’s response: “To inspire people around the world to follow their dreams and never give up”.

There are many possible roads to innovation. Successful innovation means defining your own road. Much like Nik Wallenda’s walk across Niagra Falls, some of the best innovations come from stepping outside your own comfort zone and balancing the many different facets of innovation.

The formula for success in innovation is about finding the middle ground, walking the tightrope between risk and innovation; between ideation and value creation. The Innovation Balancing Act.

Successfully managing the process of innovation ensures the outcome results in a superior return on investment (ROI).

Risk/Innovation

It’s safe to say that companies are not naturally inclined to try new approaches without clear evidence that those approaches are likely to work. Like many innovators, you may find yourself struggling to innovate in advance of an anticipated economic recovery, while still working to keep costs down in a decidedly uncertain business arena. To increase initiative and innovation, you have to encourage and even embrace failure. You must have a willingness to invest without ROI assurance (see Innovation is Creativity X Risk Taking).

Keep in mind:

  • Milton Hershey started three unsuccessful companies before Hershey’s Chocolate.
  • Michael Jordan was told he was too short to play on his high school varsity basketball team.
  • The Beatles were originally rejected by Decca Recording studios, who said “we don’t like their sound” and “they have no future in show business”.
  • At age 30, Apple’s Board of Directors decided to take the business in a different direction, and Steve Jobs was fired from the company he created. Not only did Jobs go back to his former company, but he changed the market in an astounding way. Jobs claims that his career success and his strong relationship with his family are both results of his termination from Apple.

Are you creating the next Hershey’s or Apple?

 Ideation/Value Creation

The key to optimizing sustainable Innovation programs is value creation. While the creation of the idea is important, the creation of value for the customer is equally paramount. Adding perceived value to a new product or service will drive ROI. The value proposition is the key to successful innovation.
Customer value can be created through the actual value-added of the new product, once you find that delicate balance between cost, price and return. Balance is found, in part, by seeking stakeholder input and customer feedback during development of any innovation process (see Value Creation).Remember:

  • A means to an end – Think of innovation as a process that uses intellectual capital to generate positive business results, new findings and as a result, even more innovation.
  • Key Considerations – Remember to monitor start-up costs, speed to market, scale to volume and other metrics.
  • Customer is king – develop an innovation with high perceived value and strong sales will follow.
  • IP Protection – IP and Patent protection lock in your competitive advantage and support sales results and market share.

You can learn more about the above points, including how to protect your ideas, by reading  Robert’s Rules of Innovation. Robert Brands is the founder of InnovationCoach.com and the author of “Robert’s Rules of Innovation”: A 10-Step Program for Corporate Survival, with Martin Kleinman, published by Wiley.

 

New Intellectual Property Exchange Streamlines Patent Trading

Tuesday, July 10th, 2012

intellectual-propertyIn the research and development industry where innovations build on top of other innovations, obtaining patents to protect intellectual property is of the utmost importance. It is critical to ensure that patents being are utilized, especially within big corporations like IBM or organizations like the Unites States Navy. Not only do patents protect newly developed products or processes, they contribute to unrealized value creation, or assets that can be explored and sold.

The latest development besides one on one deals and patent auctions is IPXI, the newly formed IP exchange created after the successful Carbon IP Exchange model. IPXI, the Intellectual Property Exchange International Inc., is the world’s first financial exchange focused solely on intellectual property rights. Some major companies like Philips, Ford and Sony have already signed up as corporate founding members and will begin trading in the near future. Since its formation in December 2011, twenty-seven organizations have joined the IP exchange, representing innovative companies with substantial IP assets in various technology markets, three Department of Energy national laboratories, top university research institutions, and a community of leading IP law firms.

IPXI revolutionizes the way patents are licensed and traded by allowing companies to buy and sell patent rights as units. These “unit license rights” can be bought and sold like shares. For example, one unit license right grants an organization a one-time right to use that particular technology on a single product. If a car manufacturing company wishes to use that technology in 50,000 cars, they purchase 50,000 unit license rights at market price. Organizations can now bypass costly litigation and use the IP exchange to harness patents as assets, monetize it fairly, and use it to spur greater innovation.

“The Exchange creates a new approach to technology licensing that overcomes the inefficiency of traditional bilateral technology license negotiations.  For the first time, companies and other entities will be able to buy and sell units of technology usage, providing improved economics, enhanced access to technology, and greater flexibility should technology needs change,” says Gerard J. Pannekoek, President and CEO of IPXI.

The concept especially benefits smaller companies with modest budgets by creating a simpler, faster, and cheaper method to obtain IP rights. And that is good news for innovators indeed.

For more tips, see “Patently Obvious” and other Chapters in “Robert’s Rules of Innovation: A 10-Step Program for Corporate Survival.”

Value Proposition: The Key to Successful Innovation

Monday, April 4th, 2011

What defines successful Innovation? Innovation is the process of using intellectual capital to create new products or services that generate positive business results in the form of financial returns. Discovering new findings then spurs more innovation which leads to further financial returns, and so on.

Innovation is successful when positive outcomes result in return on investment (ROI). That is why Value Creation is so important. Adding perceived value to a new product or service will drive ROI. The value proposition is the key to successful innovation. Develop an innovation with high perceived value to your customer, and strong sales will follow.

It’s all about understanding your customer and giving them what they want. Customer input and feedback is key. Look at Ford for example. The car manufacturer observed and listened to their large customer base on what they wanted in a car. They launched the “Your Ideas” initiative that invited people to make suggestions for improvement in all areas of comfort, convenience, connectivity, performance and safety. The result? Ford added iPod, MP3 player and USB connections, touch screens, voice activated communication systems, intelligent push-start buttons and more. Sales are soaring – not because of the traditional four wheels and performance but because of perceived value added features. Ford Motor Company now has the highest customer satisfaction rating among all major automakers.

When was the last time you tried or experienced your product or customer experience? Create value and not just onerous processes. Consumer input should be considered at multiple stages of your new product development process in order to increase perceived value. Enhanced product value means higher margins, greater returns, improved loyalty and increased stakeholder value.

Finally, when you find that delicate balance between cost, manufacturability and consumer perceived value, be sure to protect your intellectual property (IP) portfolio through patents. Invest the time and money into constantly updating patents and managing your product or service portfolio because it will lock in the value of your Innovation IP.

For more tips on Innovation and Value Creation, look for Robert’s Rules of Innovation. Robert Brands is the founder of InnovationCoach.com and the author of “Robert’s Rules of Innovation”: A 10-Step Program for Corporate Survival, with Martin Kleinman, published by Wiley.

Innovate to Thrive: Time to Open the Throttle

Sunday, October 17th, 2010

As leaders search for the next process that will transform their organizations into category leaders, for many – it seems – the answer is close at hand: Innovation.

Over the past several weeks and 10 posts on the Vistage Blog , we’ve reviewed key imperatives that formed “Robert’s Rules of Innovation” and that together create the foundation upon which to build, improve, sustain and grow an organization’s innovation mandate.

Consider this the closing chapter in an 11-step treatise on putting what you’ve read into action. First, a brief summary…

Consider the lesson on the first imperative – Inspire and Initiate – to realize the steps necessary. The power of inspiration cannot be over-estimated in the process of innovation. Inspire your people, and then hit the throttle. (more…)

The Reward of Innovation

Sunday, September 5th, 2010

Innovation is ultimately about return on investment at the end of the New Product Development process. With the success of a new product launch, everyone benefits – from shareholders and company employees to the consumers. Innovation done well reaps market share gain, new products and new features. Essentially, everyone wins.

The last imperative of Robert’s Rules of Innovation is Net Results, Net Reward, meaning recognizing the people who contributed to the development of a new product. It’s important to reward actions with incentives for sustainable effort.
(more…)

Redefining Innovation’s True Reward: Amassing Intellectual Property and Value Creation

Friday, July 23rd, 2010

What is the ultimate goal of process-driven innovation? Open a bottle of Coca-Cola – and read its performance reports – to get a true taste of the answer.

In 1980, the Coca-Cola Company was struggling, and its market share was underperforming compared to its competitors. So at a worldwide management conference in 1981, CEO Roberto Críspulo Goizueta decided to refocus the entire organization on putting value creation first.
(more…)